Table of Contents In this article we are going to look deep into standard rate turns and examine the math and some of physics behind them. We are also going to look at the "rule of thumb" (mental calculation) methods that pilots use to estimate the bank angle required to achieve a standard rate turn. We will verify how precise are they in comparison to an exact formula that we will construct. Defining Standard Rate Turn Definition: A standard rate turn is maneuver in which an aircraft turns at a rate 3o per second (3o/s) . If this turn is held for exactly two minutes (120 seconds) the aircraft will complete a 360o turn since: 3o/s · 120s = 360o
The bank required to achieve standard rate changes with your true airspeed (TAS). The higher that speed, the greater the bank angle will need to be in order to achieve a standard rate turn.
Fig 1-1 Instruments used to measure rate of turn in aircraft. Figure 1-1 a shows an analog turn coordinator instrument that currently indicates a standard rate turn to the right (tip of the miniature aircraft wing on right marking). Figure 1-1 b shows the same situation on a digital display (magenta arc on second right marking). Note that these instruments are showing how fast the heading of the aircraft is changing (rate of turn). They do not show bank directly. Estimating the Bank Angle to Achieve a Standard Rate Turn
Fig 1-2 Attitude indicator instruments used to bank the aircraft. When banking the aircraft to execute a standard rate turn, it is useful for pilots to have an approximate idea of how much that bank should be for standard rate. They will be using the attitude indicator (Figure 1-2 a & b) first to bank the aircraft and once they are at the approximate bank, they will then rely on the turn coordinator instrument (Figure 1-1 a & b) to adjust the initial bank so that a standard rate turn is established. The following was taken directly from a paragraph in the FAA-H-8083-15A Instrument Flying Handbook, Page 5-19 and 5-20, 2008 Edition, published by United States Department of transportation, Federal Aviation Administration Air Men Testing Standards Branch: "A rule of thumb to determine the approximate angle of bank required for a standard rate turn is to use 15 percent of the true airspeed. A simple way to determine this amount is to divide the airspeed by 10 and add one-half the result. For example, at 100 knots, approximately 15o of bank is required (100 รท 10 = 10 + 5 = 15); at 120 knots, approximately 18o of bank is needed for a standard rate turn." in other words: Where:
There are also some variations to this approximation method. One of them is: Basically meaning: take 10% of the true airspeed then add five to get the approximate bank angle in degrees for standard rate turn. This equation will later be referred to as equation
II - Forces Acting on Aircraft (constant altitude) We're going to begin by looking at the physics and geometry of a standard rate turn starting with the straight and level flight before the turn. Straight and Level Flight Before the Turn Fig 2-1 Aircraft flying straight and level Figure 2-1 shows our hypothetical aircraft flying straight and level. The left image is the top map view, and the image on the right represents the aircraft as seen from behind. Fig 2-2 Aircraft flying straight and level (thrust, drag, lift and weight forces) Figure 2-2 on the left shows the thrust (T) and drag (D) forces. Since the aircraft's true air speed (TAS) will remain constant during straight and level flight and then subsequently during the execution of the standard rate turn in our hypothetical example, we are not going to concern ourselves with these forces. Also note that thrust (T) and drag (D) will cancel each other out both before and during the turn, but they will not remain the same. During the turn, drag (D) will increase due to the need to generate more lift; as a result more thrust (T), added by the pilot, will be necessary to compensate for this increase in drag. This thrust increase is necessary if airspeed is to remain constant. We will examine why lift has to increase in more detail shortly. Figure 2-2 on the right shows the lift (L) and the opposing weight (W) force during straight and level flight. During this flight condition these forces cancel each other out. That is why the aircraft will remain at its altitude and flight path (provided it is not already climbing or descending) and will not accelerate vertically (begin to ascend or descend). During Standard Rate Turn Fig 2-3 Aircraft banking (lift and weight forces) Figure 2-3 on the right shows the lift (L) and weight (W) forces when the aircraft banks at an angle Fig 2-4 Aircraft banking (lift components and weight forces) In figure 2-4, the lift force (L), which we can refer to as total lift, is shown broken down to its horizontal (LH) and vertical (LV) components. These are not additional forces, they are simply another way to represent the total lift force (L) . The total lift force (L) can also be thought as a resultant force of those horizontal (LH) and vertical (LV) lift forces. Now we can see more clearly how the vertical lift (LV) counteracts the weight (W). When the aircraft banked, the lift force increased such that it's vertical component (LV) remained equal and opposite to the weight (W) force. Otherwise the aircraft's altitude would change. Therefore the vertical component of lift (LV) and weight force (W) will cancel each other out during the bank, leaving the horizontal component of lift (LH) as the remaining force. This horizontal component of lift (LH) force is what will make the aircraft turn in a circular flight path. IMPORTANT: We are assuming the turn is coordinated (ball centered). There should be no slip or skid.
III - Obtaining an Exact Equation for the Bank Angle Required Our goal, now that we understand the forces involved in the turn, is to obtain an exact equation. The input will be the aircraft's true airspeed (TAS) and output will be the bank angle Fig 3-1 Lift force, its components and relationship with the bank angle Let's begin by examining how lift relates to the bank angle during our turn (see Fig 3-1).
Fig 3-2 The lift force and its components form a right triangle. In figure 3-2, the side opposite to
Fig 3-3 Trigonometric solution to the right triangle Rotate that triangle 90o clockwise and you can see that As mentioned previously, the horizontal component of lift (LH) is the only force that does not cancel out with the others during the turn and is what makes the aircraft fly in a circle. From physics (laws of motion: centripetal force) we know that the force that causes an object to move in a circle is the centripetal force. It can be described by the following equation:
where CF is the centripetal force on the object, m is its mass, v is the speed of the object, and r is the radius of the circular path that the object is moving on. Since this force has to be equal to LH, we have:
Substituting LH for CF in equation
We also know that the vertical component of lift (LV) equals the weight of the aircraft (W):
W can be defined by another equation from physics:
where W is the aircraft's weight, g is the acceleration of gravity, and m is its mass. We can substitute
Now we can substitute
We are almost there. The mass "m" cancels out. The quantity v is the aircraft's speed, and we know that; "g" can be obtained easily from publications; however, "r" is not known. We know that we are turning at a constant bank, speed and altitude. Turning also happens at a certain constant rate (3o per second for standard rate). This basically means that the heading will be changing at this rate, which we will call Fig 3-4 Aircraft flying in a circle - change in heading We will also call Fig 3-5 Aircraft flying in a circle - angular speed and aircraft speed The rate or speed that From physics (kinematics: angular speed) the radius "r" is a function of "v" and
Great! We know Now we can substitute
This is the equation we wanted. However, it is not exactly ready for use by pilots yet. The units in the equations above must be consistent. To do that we have to pick a system of units. If the units we need are in a different system than the one we pick, then we must convert each different unit individually. Let's pick the International Standard of Units (SI) as our standard (see table 3-1 below).
Adapting the equation for units used in aviation We will keep acceleration of gravity (g) in m/s2 since it is the most common unit for g. For the remaining units the table below gives each unit and the number that it has to be multiplied by for it to be converted to SI units and used in equation
Applying all the conversion multipliers in equation
Now let's use some more user-friendly names for the symbols:
Equation Bank Angle = 57.296 · atan (0.0027467 · TAS) Equation
Arctangent Approximation Under certain conditions: is a very good approximation of: Note that the atan (arctangent) function must be in radians.
Table 4-1 above shows several values for x and the corresponding y results. Decimals were placed to indicate the precision that the calculations were made. Notice that for values under 0.268 the difference is 2% or less.
In chart 4-1 you can visualize how the y = atan (x) function is very close to the straight line given by y = x for values closer to zero. It is hard to see what this means for us when we are working in radians. The arctangent (atan) function in radians can be converted to degrees by simply multiplying it by a conversion constant c1. Therefore we have:
and the simplified function will be:
Table 4-2 shows the values of y in degrees. For example when the value of the arctangent in degrees is 20, the simplified function will have a value of 20.9. This difference of 0.9 is approximately a 4% error. The higher the amount of degrees, the higher the error. For 35o the error is 15%. However for smaller angles the error is practically negligible.
Chart 4-2 helps visualize how the error is very minute for small angles and gets progressively larger once you pass about 25o. Applying the Arctangent Approximation to our Formula for Bank Angle Bank Angle = 57.296 · atan (0.0027467 · TAS) Applying our simplification for arctangent, equation Bank Angle Once again " Bank Angle Notice how remarkably close equation or: Bank Angle We had to go a long ways, but now we know where the rule of thumb formula comes from and what modifications had to be made to the exact formula in order to obtain it. Remember that Bank Angle in these two formulas is in degrees and TAS is in knots. In summary we have the following (see table 4-3 below) equations for obtaining the bank angle for standard rate turn as a function of true airspeed (TAS):
The two rule of thumb equations that we discussed in the beginning of the article were numbered
At Low Speeds:
Chart 5-1 graphs each equation. The solid blue line is the exact equation
In chart 5-2 we can take a closer look at the deviations (errors) from the exact equation . Of the two equations that can be mentally calculated, once again equation
From chart 5-3 it seems equation
Chart 5-4 gives a clearer look at how much each equation is deviating from the exact equation. Even though equation
Its is probably best to use equation Most pilots in heavier commercial aircraft normally don't exceed banks beyond 30o. However notice how in chart 5-3, in the previous section, that at slightly above 200 knots, the bank angle for standard rate will exceed 30o. To address this issue pilots will many times do a ½ standard rate turn. In other words instead of taking 2 minutes to complete a 360o turn, it will take 4 minutes. For a ½ standard rate turn, since: 4 minutes = 4 · 60 seconds = 240 seconds the aircraft will have to turn at a rate of: 360o / 240= 1.5o per second Now we will go back to equation
Substituting: the Rate of Turn = 1.5o/s for standard rate; using the conventional standard value for g, which is 9.80665 m/s2; and evaluating up to 5 significant digits we get: Bank Angle = 57.296 · atan (0.0013734 · TAS) which we will call equation Bank Angle Now if we multiply the two numbers in our equation we will have: Bank Angle The equation above is for a ½ standard rate turn. It is basically the same as taking the approximate equation Bank Angle Let's go ahead then and take the other equations that we used for standard rate turn (
The rule of thumb equations Comparing the Approximations for ½ Standard Rate to the Exact Formula At Low Speeds:
Chart 6-1 graphs each equation. The solid blue line is the exact equation
In chart 6-2 we can take a closer look at the deviations from the exact equation (errors). Equation
From chart 6-3 it looks like the bank angle exceeds 30o at around 420 knots. The chart below will give a better picture of the errors.
Chart 6-4 equation Conclusion: If you used equation
What about if TAS is in kilometers per hour (km/hr)? It is probably not necessary to go in detail over the whole process again, but here are the equations:
As before, we will keep acceleration of gravity (g) in m/s2 since it is the most common unit for g. For the remaining units the following table gives each unit and the number that it has to be multiplied by for it to be converted to SI units and used in equation
Applying all the conversion multipliers in equation
More user-friendly names for the symbols yields:
Reducing this equation to something more usable. Substituting: the Rate of Turn = 3o/s for standard rate; use the conventional standard for g, which is 9.80665 m/s2; and evaluating up to 5 significant digits we get: Bank Angle = 57.296 · atan (0.0014831 · TAS) Equation Applying our simplification of arctangent, equation Bank Angle Now if we multiply the two numbers in our equation we will have: Bank Angle Equation We'll try the following equations that are easy to calculate and are somewhat close to equation
At Low Speeds:
Chart 7-1 graphs each equation. The solid blue line is the exact equation
In chart 7-2 we can take a closer look at the deviations (errors) from the exact equation. Apart from the exact equation
From chart 7-3 It looks like the bank angle passes 30o at around 400 km/hr. The chart below will give a better picture of the errors.
As mentioned previously, equation Conclusion: The best equation will really depend on your speed range:
To make things even simpler, if you don't mind a little more error from 100 - 200 knots, you can use:
VIII - Units and Variables Used
As we constructed our mathematical model for standard rate turns we came across many formulas that are useful. In this section lets quickly highlight a few. A - Radius of Turn Formula (as a function of speed and rate of turn)
where r is the radius of turn, v is the speed of the aircraft and
Renaming r, v and
where RadiusOfTurn, TAS and RateOfTurn are given in Nm, knots and o/s respectively. Evaluating
For a standard rate turn (RateOfTurn = 3o/s) ONLY, we have: RadiusOfTurn = 0.00053052 · TAS where RadiusOfTurn and TAS are given in Nm and knots respectively. This equation is exact up to five significant digits.
Equation
where r is the radius of turn, v is the speed of the aircraft, g is the acceleration of gravity and
Renaming r, v and
where RadiusOfTurn, TAS and BankAngle are given in Nm, knots and o respectively. Evaluating
Load factor is defined as the total lift to weight ratio:
Where L is the total lift and W is the weight of the aircraft. We now need to find an equation for L:
From our triangle that we got from analyzing the geometry of a standard rate turn in section III we can get the following equation that will give us total lift (L):
Where
we can substitute
we can substitute
Notice how weight (W) cancelled out. Note that
Renaming
Evaluating
where BankAngle is given in o. The charts below graph this formula.
Chart 9-1 graphs the load factor at bank angle up to 80o. At 80o the load factor is almost 6. This would mean that a pilot performing a level turn at this bank angle would experience almost 6 times the force of gravity (or 6g's).
Chart 9-2 graphs the load factor at bank angles from 80o to 89o. Notice how abruptly the load factor increases. As the bank angle approaches 90o, the load factor approaches infinity (not possible to show in the graph).
All rights reserved to Luiz Roberto Monteiro de Oliveira. |